This is a chunky, stick-to-your ribs vegetable soup that’s perfect for a cold winter day. It’s not chile pepper hot, just loaded with spices. I start by dicing butternut squash with the skin on, which adds a rustic texture to the soup and keeps the squash from completely falling apart. I use lard to sauté the squash, onion, celery, and carrot so you get a little pork flavor. You could use bacon fat instead. The fat helps to caramelize the vegetables in the pan, creating a deep, savory flavor. The spices are basically warm Indian spices along with some Espelette pepper for heat and pomegranate molasses adds some acidity and sweetness. Look for it in Middle Eastern grocery stores and online. Or make it at home by juicing some pomegranates and boiling down the juice until it’s syrupy, like thin honey.
Feeds 8 to 10 hungry folks
Butternut squash - 2 tall boy–sized, about 3 ½ pounds total
Lard or bacon grease - ¼ cup
Onion - 1 softball-size, cut into ¾-inch dice
Celery - 3 ribs, cut into ¾-inch dice
Salt - 2 tablespoons
Carrot - 1 huge one, peeled and cut into ¾-inch dice
Masala punjabi chole curry - 2 tablespoons
Sumatra ground cinnamon - 1 teaspoon
No-salt chicken stock - 5 ½ cups
Sherry vinegar - 1 tablespoon
Lemon juice - 2 teaspoons
Pomegranate molasses - 2 tablespoons
1. Trim the ends from the squash and cut in half lengthwise. Scrape
out and discard the pulp and seeds and chop the squash into bite-size
chunks. You’ll have about 12 cups. And, yes, you leave the skin on.
2. Melt the lard in a 4-quart Dutch oven over medium-high heat. Layer
the vegetables and salt in the pot in the following order: onion first, then
celery, then 1 tablespoon of the salt, then the squash, and finally the
carrot. Let the mixture cook until the vegetables on the bottom start
to brown, about 5 minutes. Then vigorously stir with a wooden spoon,
scraping up all the browned bits and stirring them into the mixture. Let
cook undisturbed for another 5 minutes, then scrape up the brown bits
and stir them into the mixture. Continue cooking and scraping up the
brown bits every 5 minutes until the squash is tender, about 15 minutes
total. This process creates deep flavor. Don’t rush it!
3. Stir in the curry and cinnamon to coat the vegetables. Add 4 cups of
the stock and bring the mixture to a boil. Cut the heat down so that the
liquid simmers and let simmer for 20 minutes, stirring now and then.
Stir in the vinegar, lemon juice, the remaining 1 tablespoon salt, and the
remaining 1 ½ cups stock; simmer for another 10 minutes.
4. Serve in warm bowls and drizzle with some pomegranate molasses.
Masala Punjabi Chole Curry – This is one of my favorite spice blends from the Dekalb Farmers Market in Atlanta, Georgia. If you can’t get your hands on this particular blend, substitute 1 tablespoon + 2 teaspoons Madras curry powder mixed with another ½ teaspoon of Sumatra cinnamon.

6 comments
Comment by Carrie on October 17, 2012 at 8:18 pm
Wow! I just read this recipe twice and got goosebumps! I’ve always loved Buttetnut Squash Soup, but this sounds AMAZING! Question, Chef – where/ when does the Chole Curry go in to the recipe? Is it just served as a side?
Comment by Marge on October 17, 2012 at 8:58 pm
Kevin, what’s the primary difference between Sumatra cinnamon and say, Vietnamese? Does it make that big a difference? And I’m a bit trepidatious about leaving the peel on the squash. Will it bite me back or does it soften up enough so that I won’t be applying bandaids to the roof of my mouth?
And, as a side note, when visiting Atlanta years ago I fell madly in love with the Dekalb Farmer’s Market. Nothing like that place ever in my experience. I would live there if I could!
Comment by kevin on October 18, 2012 at 10:10 am
Hi Marge. All varieties of cinnamon are slightly different from one another in intensity and also spiciness. If you only have a particular variety available then you can substitute, but be aware that sometimes it isn’t a 1 for 1 substitution. As for the rind, I promise it will not be hard to eat. It will soften, though not entirely, and lend the dish a more interesting texture as the pieces of squash will stay in chunks. Good luck.
Comment by kevin on October 18, 2012 at 10:11 am
It goes in while you are caramelizing the squash and other veggies in the fat. You want to toast the spices to draw as much of their flavor out as possible.
Comment by Tiffany on October 22, 2012 at 8:46 pm
I made this over the weekend as I am always looking for satisfying veggie-focused dishes for meat eaters, and this one delivered! I oven fried bacon while I did the veg prep so I could use the bacon fat. Wasn’t sure what “tall boy” meant (unless it was squash shaped like a beer bottle) but I did use more squash than the recipe called for. Leaving the skin on was perfect for the texture–it was kind of like when you leave the peel on an apple and cook it, but the squash has a more buttery mouth feel and the rind has more substance but is soft; it’s also not papery or thin. Unexpectedly nice! (I was skeptical about that too).
When I make it again, the main thing I need to sort out is the spice. I couldn’t find Madras curry powder at the store. I found a ton of recipes with just as many comments/arguments regarding what the “authentic” blend was. I didn’t feel like busting out my entire spice drawer to mix it up, so I punted and just used the curry powder and cinnamon I had. I think this was a mistake. I don’t know if I accidentally added too much cinnamon, but it made it smell too sweet…if that makes any sense. When I make it again I will have to either try mixing my own or track down the right curry and cut back on the cinnamon. I think I just didn’t get quite the right balance there.
The other thing I couldn’t find is sherry vinegar, so I found a post where someone actually did a taste compare and said they thought 1/2 balsamic and 1/2 apple cider vinegar was the closest so I went with that.
When I tasted before serving, it felt like something was missing…it was the pomegranate molasses! Adding that to the top of the soup before serving adds a beautiful swirl of color and a little sweet tang.
I’m not ashamed to report I also chopped up a little bacon to top it with.
Kevin, I hope I get to meet you at the Harvester’s throwdown tomorrow night– and I hope that your cookbook has more recipes like this. Thanks!
Comment by Leandro on October 30, 2012 at 5:06 am
Oh my goodness! This soup is so good and htreay! I loved it and can’t wait for some more. I loved it warmed over the next day for lunch, too. It’s a healthy meal in a bowl. This gets a 5-star rating from me!
NOTE: By submitting a comment you grant Chef Kevin Gillespie a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. Inappropriate and irrelevant comments will be removed at an admin’s discretion. Your email is used for verification purposes only, it will never be shared.